Blog

Jesús Avendaño
·
A $48 order clears checkout on the Basic plan through Shopify Payments. The receipt looks clean. Then a second gateway fee lands because the customer paid through a backup processor, and a partial refund later leaves the fixed portion of the fee behind. The rate you compared last quarter never included either of those.
You already know the headline card rate for a US online sale. The figure that changes pricing is the effective rate: total fee dollars divided by the revenue that produced them. Route part of the volume through PayPal, a buy-now-pay-later button, or a backup gateway and those orders stop matching the Shopify Payments card rate. Shopify's plan surcharge stacks on the provider's own charge. The processing-fees line on the P&L will not show which orders opened the gap.
Treat the fee as a per-order cost and subtract it before you call the order profitable. Which products you push, which discounts you run, and which payment methods sit at the top of checkout all shift once that subtraction is in the number.
Shopify Payment Processing Fees at a Glance
A US online card sale handled by Shopify Payments costs 2.9% plus $0.30 on the Basic plan. That's your anchor, and every other number below is a variation on it.
Shopify payment rates by plan (US)
Plan | Online card rate | In-person card rate | Third-party transaction fee |
|---|---|---|---|
Basic | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.6% + $0.10 | 2% |
Grow | 2.7% + $0.30 | 2.5% + $0.10 | 1% |
Advanced | 2.5% + $0.30 | 2.4% + $0.10 | 0.6% |
Plus | From 2.25% + $0.30 | From 2.3% + $0.10 | 0.2% |
Those online and in-person figures are Shopify's published US rates for standard cards, with in-person processing at 2.6%, 2.5% and 2.4% plus $0.10 across the three self-serve plans (Shopify's credit card processing fee guide). Premium cards and cards issued abroad cost more than the standard rate, and Shopify publishes those separately.
Three fees, three different triggers
Most confusion comes from treating these as one charge. They aren't.
The online card rate applies whenever Shopify Payments handles a card-not-present sale. The in-person rate applies at point of sale, and it's materially cheaper per transaction, so don't blend the two channels into a single average unless you know the split. The third-party transaction fee applies only when a gateway other than Shopify Payments processes the payment, and it's a Shopify charge, not a processor charge.
Reading the table takes about thirty seconds. Find your plan. Match the rate to the channel the order came through. Add the third-party fee only for orders where an external gateway took the money. Everything here is US pricing; other markets have their own schedules and their own card mix.
How the Fee Is Calculated on Each Order
A card fee works like a courier: a fixed handling charge per parcel, plus a percentage of the parcel's declared value. Ship a cheap envelope and the handling charge dominates. Ship something expensive and the percentage does.
Core idea: the percentage scales with the order; the fixed fee does not.
That single mechanic explains why a store with a $30 average order and a store with a $300 average order can pay wildly different effective rates on identical plans.
The four-step calculation
Take the amount the customer pays. That's the order total after discounts, plus tax and shipping where applicable. Not the product subtotal you'd prefer to quote.
Multiply by your plan's percentage. Basic uses 2.9%, Grow 2.7%, Advanced 2.5%. The percentage moves with the plan, not with the order size.
Add the fixed $0.30. It applies once per transaction regardless of value, which is why small baskets feel expensive.
Add the third-party fee, but only when an external gateway processed the payment. If Shopify Payments handled it, this step doesn't exist.
The Shopify Payments rule matters here. When Shopify Payments is the sole provider, Shopify states there are no monthly, setup or hidden Shopify Payments fees beyond the card-processing rate and the store's subscription, and orders taken through Shop Pay, Shop Pay Installments, cash on delivery or bank transfer carry no third-party transaction fee at all (Shopify's cost of Shopify Payments). The rate itself varies by plan, market and card type, so check your country's schedule rather than assuming one global percentage.
Run the arithmetic on a $100 order paid entirely through Shopify Payments on Basic: 2.9% is $2.90, plus $0.30, and you're at $3.20 with nothing else to add.
Now run it on a $25 order. The percentage gives you $0.73 and the fixed fee adds $0.30, taking the total to $1.03. The fixed charge alone is nearly a third of what you pay, and that's before any discount code has cut the order further.
Five Factors That Move Your Effective Rate
The advertised rate is a starting point, not an outcome. Effective rate equals total fees divided by the revenue those fees were charged on, and five things move that ratio away from the plan headline.
Store owners routinely compare processors by nominal rate and then wonder why the bill doesn't match. Shopify's own documentation describes the stacking problem directly: a third-party processor charges its own processing fee, and Shopify separately applies a plan-based third-party transaction fee on top of it (Shopify's third-party transaction fees).
The factors that move the number:
Plan tier. A higher plan shaves 0.2 points off the card rate and drops the third-party fee sharply, but you pay more per month whether or not you sell anything. Small stores often lose money upgrading.
Provider mix. The cheapest processor on paper can be the most expensive in practice. Its advertised rate has to be stacked on Shopify's plan percentage, and the surcharge can swallow the entire saving.
Card type and origin. Premium rewards cards, business cards and cards issued outside your home country all price differently from a standard domestic consumer card. A store selling B2B is paying a different blend than one selling to consumers.
Order value. The fixed per-transaction amount is a bigger share of a $25 basket than a $250 one, so two stores on identical plans can post effective rates a full point apart.
Refunds and failed payments. A fee charged on the original transaction isn't automatically handed back when you refund.
Switching processors doesn't reliably reduce payment costs when the plan surcharge and the routing mix outweigh a lower advertised rate. Changing the mix of who processes what, and renegotiating your plan tier, moves the number further.
Measure each of those five factors on the same basis, fees over revenue for a fixed period, and you'll see which one is inflating your cost. Most stores find it's the mix, not the rate.
What a Real Order Costs at Different Values
Start with the most common order size. On a $50 online card order, Shopify Payments costs $1.75 on Basic, $1.65 on Grow and $1.55 on Advanced, before any premium-card or international adjustment. The spread between the cheapest and priciest plan is 20 cents.
Card fee per order by value and plan (US online)
Order value | Basic | Grow | Advanced |
|---|---|---|---|
$25 | $1.03 | $0.98 | $0.93 |
$50 | $1.75 | $1.65 | $1.55 |
$100 | $3.20 | $3.00 | $2.80 |
$200 | $6.10 | $5.70 | $5.30 |
Twenty cents looks like rounding until you multiply it. At 500 orders a month at $50 each, moving from Basic to Advanced saves $100 a month, and that's the figure you set against the difference in subscription price before deciding anything.
Rule of thumb: an upgrade pays for itself only when the per-order saving multiplied by your monthly order count exceeds the monthly subscription gap.
If your orders cluster nearer $25 than $100, the fixed portion takes a bigger bite and the plan spread per order narrows, which makes upgrading harder to justify. Check your average order value before you model any of this, because a plan decision built on the wrong basket size is just a guess with a spreadsheet around it.
Where the external gateway changes the answer
Now put a third-party processor on the order. A $100 order with no discount, tax or shipping, run through an external gateway, adds $2.00 in Shopify third-party fees on Basic on top of whatever that processor charges. The same order on Advanced adds $0.60. Shopify calculates that fee on the amount represented by products after discounts, plus tax and shipping, so a heavily discounted order reduces the base but doesn't eliminate the charge (Shopify's third-party fee formula). The plan rates themselves are listed on Shopify's pricing page.
This is the number that breaks the comparison. A processor advertising 2.4% looks cheaper than Shopify Payments at 2.9% until you add the plan percentage. On Basic, 2.4% plus 2% is 4.4%, and the store that "saved" 0.5 points is paying 1.5 points more.
The cheapest external processor is rarely the cheapest total option, because its rate never travels alone. Every figure in this section is a US online card rate; in-person and international orders price differently.
Currency, Refunds and Cross-Border Costs
Think of a currency conversion fee the way you'd think of an exchange kiosk's commission on the way in. You pay it at the counter when the money arrives, and handing the money back later doesn't get the commission returned.
Shopify charges that conversion fee when a customer pays in a currency different from your Shopify Payments payout currency. It's 1.5% for US stores and 2% for stores in the UK, EEA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and other listed regions, charged on the original transaction, and it is not refunded when a foreign-currency order is refunded (Shopify's local currencies and markets settings).
Run a $200 order in a non-payout currency from a UK store. The 2% conversion charge is $4.00. Refund the whole order and you still paid it, so a high-return category absorbs that cost twice over: once on the sale that shipped and once on the sale that came back.
The refund you can't fully reverse
Two separate charges stack on an international order. You pay the standard processing fee on the transaction, and you pay the conversion fee on top when the customer's currency differs from your payout currency. Shopify distinguishes domestic processing, where the card is issued in the same country or region as your store, from cross-border processing on cards issued elsewhere, and local-currency sales carry the regular fee plus the conversion charge, with rates that vary by card type and location (Shopify's payment transactions documentation).
That rules out a shortcut plenty of operators take: applying the domestic rate to every order regardless of where the card came from. A store with a 2.9% plus $0.30 domestic rate can't assume that figure holds on a card issued abroad, and profitability by country will be wrong if it does.
A processor with a slightly higher headline card rate can be cheaper overall if it settles in local currencies and removes conversion events. The rate matters less than how many times currency gets converted on the way to your bank.
Chargebacks are harder still, because the amount debited in your payout currency uses the exchange rate at the date of the chargeback rather than the date of the sale. The original order doesn't change; the cost of it does.
Building Fees Into Your Profit Calculation
A $100 order that looks like $41.80 of contribution can shrink once every fee that hit the payout is subtracted, not only the headline card rate. Those fees belong in the cost column before contribution is judged.
Start with the order total after discounts. Use what the customer paid, including tax and shipping where the fee base includes them.
Subtract product cost. Landed cost, including freight and duties, not only the wholesale price.
Subtract the card fee using the plan formula. Percentage times the order total, plus the fixed amount.
Subtract the third-party fee if an external gateway processed the payment. Nothing to subtract if Shopify Payments handled it.
Subtract the currency conversion fee on foreign-currency orders. That charge does not automatically return on a refund.
Subtract refund and chargeback losses tied to that order, including fees that survive the reversal.
Subtract the ad spend and shipping allocated to that order. A blended cost per order is usable. Leaving it out is not.
Illustrative profit waterfall for one $100 order
Line item | Note | Amount |
|---|---|---|
Order total after discounts | Customer paid, US online card | $100.00 |
Product cost | Landed cost of goods | -$35.00 |
Shopify Payments fee (Basic) | 2.9% of $100 plus $0.30 | -$3.20 |
Gross after payment fees | Before ads and shipping | $61.80 |
Allocated ad spend | Campaign cost per order | -$20.00 |
Contribution | Before shipping and overhead | $41.80 |
Swap in a real product cost and the picture moves. A 30% discount code on the same order cuts the revenue base while the fixed portion of the card fee stays put, so the effective rate on the discounted sale runs higher than the plan rate implies.
Shopify's own analytics do not count ad spend, payment fees, shipping, or fixed costs when they report profit. The admin figure and a full contribution figure measure different things. Extending contribution margin per unit to the order is how the card fee, a third-party surcharge, and a refund loss show up before profit is called.
Payment records stay with Shopify. Cifra reads that order data from Shopify, so adding it does not replace Shopify reporting. It adds the costs admin profit leaves out, including ad spend, fees, shipping, and fixed costs, and shows profit by product and by discount code.
Audit Your Payment Fees Before Your Next Pricing Decision
Three checks, run in this order, will tell you whether your effective rate is a pricing problem or a routing problem.
List which providers handled your orders in the last 30 days. Any order that went through an external gateway carries a third-party fee, and a gateway you turned on for one campaign two years ago may still be taking a slice of checkout.
Divide total payment fees by total card revenue for the same period. Compare that effective rate against your plan's headline rate. A gap larger than the card mix explains is the surcharge talking.
Rerun the profit calculation for your top two products and your largest discount code. Discounts shrink the fee base but not the fixed charge, so the code that looks like your best performer can be the one with the thinnest contribution.
If you'd rather model it than reconstruct it, our Shopify fee calculator lets you pick a plan and a payment method, then enter average order value and monthly orders to see the fee on each order and the total Shopify takes each month. It covers US online rates only; other countries and in-person sales price differently and need their own figures.
If your effective rate comes in higher than the plan rate suggests, check the provider mix before you switch processors. Changing gateways to fix a surcharge problem usually moves the cost sideways.
When the fee is the thing you can't see clearly, the rest of the P&L tends to drift with it. Cifra pulls your Shopify orders, discounts and refunds together with ad spend and product costs, so the fee lands in the cost column on the order that generated it and the profit figure you're looking at is the one after everything came out. You can see how the Shopify profit analytics handle fees, contribution and channel mix before you change a single price.
Jesús Avendaño
·